| |
There
are a number of good introductions to real options (see
the web resources for a full listing). Here is the starter
from Expectations Investing: Reading Stock Prices
for Better Returns by Alfred Rappaport and Michael
Mauboussin. (HBS Press, 2001, Chapter 8) Mauboussin
is the Chief Investment Strategist at Credit Suisse
First Boston, and you can read a thought piece on real
options he wrote for money managers called Get
Real.
"The
real-options approach applies financial options theory
to real investments, such as manufacturing plants, product
line extensions, and research and development. A financial
option gives the owner the right, but not the obligation,
to buy or sell a security at a given price. Analogously,
companies that make strategic investments have the right,
but not the obligation, to exploit these opportunities
in the future.
Real
options take a number of forms, including the following:
-
If an initial investment works out well, then management
can exercise the option to expand its commitment
to the strategy. For example, a company that enters
a new geographic market may build a distribution center
that it can expand easily if market demand materializes.
- An
initial investment can serve as a platform to extend
a company's scope into related market opportunities.
For example, Amazon.com's substantial investment to
develop its customer base, brand name and information
infrastructure for its core book business created
a portfolio of real options to extend its operations
into a variety of new businesses.
- Management
may begin with a relatively small trial investment
and create an option to abandon the project
if results are unsatisfactory. Research and development
spending is a good example. A company's future investment
in product development often depends on specific performance
targets achieved in the lab. The option to abandon
research projects is valuable because the company
can make investments in stages rather than all up-front.
Each
of these options - expand, extend, and abandon - owes
its value to the flexibility it gives the company. Flexibility
adds value in two ways. First, management can defer
an investment. Because of the time value of money, managers
are better off paying the investment cost later rather
than sooner. Second, the value of the project can change
before the option expires. If the value goes up, we're
better off. If the value goes down, we're no worse off
because we don't have to invest in the project.
Traditional
valuation tools, including discounted cash flow, can't
value the contingent nature of the exploitation decision:
"If things go well, then we'll add some capital."
|

|