What
the Academics Say
What Our Readers Say
What Reviewers Say
Full review of Alex Triantis
What Jeff Skilling, former CEO of Enron
says
What
the Academics Say
"This book provides and excellent introduction to the
real options way of thinking."
Alexander Triantis, University of Maryland, in Risk
Magazine, September 1999. (The full
review)
"Real
Options is an exciting, accessible introduction to one
of the most useful innovations in modern finance. Filled
with lively examples from various industries, the book
reveals the power of real options in business planning."
David Luenberger, Professor of Engineering-Economic
Systems and Operations Research, Stanford University,
and author of Investment Science.
"This
new book by Martha Amram and Nalin Kullatilaka provides
a much-needed treatment of real options theory aimed
at the practitioner. It is comprehensive, highly readable,
and replete with useful examples. Every corporate finance
practitioner should have a copy of Real Options on hand."
Robert Pindyck, Mistubishi Bank Professor of Applied
Economics, MIT Sloan School of Management and coauthor
of Investment Under Uncertainty
"Many
long-term investments (e.g., plant or R&D) generate
contingencies and real options. The term "real options"
differentiates these options from financial options,
which are the right to buy or sell securities. For example,
R&D expense cannot produce a positive net cash flow
but does create options to make additional investments.
Traditional discounted cash flow methods (NPV and IRR)
do not accurately value investments with contingencies
and options, whereas a real optoins approach to capital
budgeting incorporates these alternatives. Many corporate
managers do not use a real option analysis because introductions
to the approach have focused on the technical aspects
of modeling and no the thought process. Amram and Kulatilaka,
consultants and educators with specialiations in real
options, have written a clear, concise explanation of
the process of applying real options. They describe
why risk increases the value of a real option since
it widens the range of potential outcomes. While a real
options approach may be intuitive for technology firms,
the authors illustrate its application to valuing startup
firms, vacant land, oil exploration, and licensing.
This book should be exceedingly useful for MBA and executive
management programs."
H. Mayo, the College of New Jersey, in Choice
>>
back to top
What
Our Readers Say
"This is the first Real Options book that targets the
general management audience and, subsequently, is not
bursting at the seams with daunting calculations and
formulas that typically turn-off even the most enthusiastic
readers. It recognizes that there is just as much power
in developing a 'real options way of thinking' as there
is in understanding the mechanics of the economic theory.
Having worked for several years in product development
where traditional financial treatments like NPV are
extremely limited, I cannot emphasize enough the power
of these frameworks. I would highly recommend this book
to people who are similarly frustrated by their current
management tools, which fail to capture the nuances
of the strategic decisions they face. Through its structure
and frequent case examples, the book makes real options
much more approachable. This increases the likelihood
that decisions will actually be influenced and enhanced
even in the face of significant uncertainty."
"At
last, a book about options with fewer equations than
case studies of real applications. Too many other books
on this vital topic concentrate on the theory, which
is very mathematical and arcane. This fails to reach
the audience who most need Option thinking: the general
manager who has to make strategic decisions in an uncertain
environment. This book addresses the general manager
through case studies shorn of obscure and unnecessary
detail."
"I
face difficult decisions every day -- the underlying
information on which to base any of my decisions is
often incomplete or uncertain. Some such decisions,
e.g. structuring the terms of a licensing agreement,
often draw upon industry-standard metrics of evaluation...
but in reality both sides are looking into a crystal
ball, weighing our risks against the possibility of
success. It is an uncomfortable state; blunders can
be costly -- as can be lost opportunities. Amram and
Kulatilaka have put together a masterful roadmap for
evaluating uncertainty -- one which can even clarify
"gut-feelings". "Real Options: Managing Strategic Investment
in an Uncertain World" was particularly easy to read
because of the many examples provided. They wrote this
as a handbook for decision-makers, the managers and
licensing executives who up to their eyeballs in choices,
negotiations, and deals -- its not just a textbook for
economics graduate students. Interestingly, I found
the Real Options strategies applied to decision-making
outside the envelope of license negotiations. I use
this strategy to value my investment of time and resources
in a variety of projects where uncertainty often seems
to be the overriding variable. Yes, risk and uncertainty
are part of real life -- they sure can make your stomach
hurt. Real Options can help you find your path and ease
the stomach-pain of choosing. "
"I've
almost completed your book now and I do really like
it. So much in fact that I've adopted it in three more
classes for this spring and summer. I've looked through
your web site and like the way the book is offered,
supported, framed... anyway, well done!"
"Your
book, Real Options, was very helpful to me in understanding
the application of the theory to several actual cases."
"It
starts from a finance/investment perspective using the
options work of Merton/Black/Scholes, but extends the
notion to contingent decision-making in a more general
sense. It is pithy and makes you think and work. I'm
confident that by the time I finish it I will be eager
to go back and understand parts of it in greater depth."
"I
have read your book with big interest. Very positive
that this is possible without being a math professional."
"I
would like to commend both you and Nalin on a well-written
and informative book- Real Options... I enjoyed your
book and believe that the area of real options and framing
is coming of age..."
"Thank
you very much for a great book on a really interesting
subject."
"I
think the book is great."
"Well-written
and very insightful!"
>>
back to top
What
Reviewers Say
What [Real Options] does is apply modern options pricing
theory to the value of options in trading assets. I
think it's a brilliant book"
Hal Rosenbluth, Executive Reader of Inc. Magazine
and CEO, Rosenbluth International, Philadelphia.
"Attention
technology company CFOs and financial managers, this
one is for you. Based on the path-breaking work of recent
Nobel Prize-winners Fischer Black, Robert Merton and
Myron Scholes concerning the pricing of financial option
contracts, this book applies the theory to "real" investment
decisions and creates a framework for decision making
that goes far beyond the standard financial models.
The authors argue that using real options valuation
increases the value of a project significantly and helps
managers concentrate capital on projects of strategic
importance, even when the payoff is not immediate. While
not for the average executive, this book is a useful
guide for financial managers to evaluate all types of
investment decisions, from R&D spending to competitive
strategy to project portfolio to product design. It's
a worthwhile overview of this important new financial
tool."
Bruce Rayner, Electronic Business
"Readable.
Makes key ideas easily accessible. A lot more like a
book length Harvard Business Review article than the
books by Trigeorgis and Dixit-Pindyck. The toughest
equation was pu2 + (1-p)d2 - [pu + (1-p)d]2 = s2 - not
that there's anything wrong with that. I'm glad I've
got it on my bookshelf."
Dr. Risk
"Huge
payoffs in business usually entail embracing lots of
risk. That's the message of Real Options, by Martha
Amram and Nalin Kulatilaka. The authors argue that standard
models of evaluating strategic investments fail to consider
the element of risk fully. "Uncertainty creates opportunities.
Managers should welcome, not fear uncertainty," write
Amram, a California-based consultant, and Kulatilaka,
a Boston University finance professor, in describing
the "real options approach." The book provides plenty
of theoretical case studies, formulas, and charts that
demonstrate how to shape business strategies using a
system based on option-pricing.
Dan Ring, Amazon.com
>>
back to top
Full
review of Alex Triantis
"Financial option traders are keenly aware that increased
volatility leads to higher option values. In contrast,
few corporate managers would welcome more uncertainty
as a way to enhance firm value. They might, however,
if they were able to recognise the "real options" embedded
in their investment opportunities. The real options
approach is a powerful new analysis technique that is
well suited for strategic decision-making and valuation
in uncertain and competitive business environments.
By following this approach, firms can realise the full
potential for their growth, flexibility, and exit options,
and equity analysts can significantly improve the accuracy
of their valuations, in particular for high-growth companies.
This
book provides and excellent introduction to this "real
options way of thinking." The authors eschew a highly
mathematical approach, and instead present the concepts
behind real options analysis in simple, intuitive terms
in order to appeal to a wider audience. Executives can
learn to appreciate the options approach as a way to
introduce the discipline of financial markets into their
firm's decision-making process. Analysts who have been
frustrated by the difficulty in valuing Internet and
telecom companies will be excited by the promise of
this new technique.
To
move from a conventional approach to a real options
approach, one must appreciate that a firm can delay
and revise its investment decisions over time, contingent
on future outcomes of key variables. The authors highlight
the importance of properly framing the decision problem,
including an identification of important sources of
uncertainty and of relevant strategic decisions. They
present a strong case that when making corporate strategic
decisions, the application frame is more important than
a precise estimation of each underlying uncertainty.
The
authors are careful to distinguish between "market risks"
and "private risks". For market risks (such as the price
of a commodity or the level of interest rates), it is
important to turn to financial markets to base estimated
of volatilities and returns on objective measures, rather
than one subjective beliefs. The discipline afforded
by turning to the financial markets is one of the key
messages of the book. However, the authors also recognise
the limitations of not being able to construct perfectly
correlated tracking portfolios, and frequently address
the issue of tracking error in their book.
There
are many other complexities that make corporate investments
and valuation problems often significantly more complicated
than simply applying financial option pricing theory.
The value and optimal exercise of one firm's growth
options may depend critically on the investment decisions
of its competitors. Managers' compensation may not properly
align their interests with those of shareholders, affecting
the value of the firm's options. The value of a firm's
real options may also depend on the firm's hedging policies.
While the authors strive for simplicity in their presentation,
they do touch on some of these complexities.
The
most attractive feature of this book and the corporate
web site www.real-options.com is a collection of 10
examples that show how the real options approach can
be used in a wide range of industries. These cases are
kept deliberately short and simple to illustrate clearly
different insights and valuation issues that are raised
earlier in the book. The examples include valuing a
start-up, exploring for oil, developing a drug, investing
in information technology infrastructure, valuing land,
writing a license and valuing production flexibility.
While the reader may be left wanting more detail about
some of the applications that really hit home, these
examples illustrate the power of using the real options
approach in practice.
If
there is any uncertainty in your mind regarding the
potential benefit of employing a real options approach
in your company, then you will probably find this book
to be an inexpensive "learning option". At a minimum,
reading this book will sharpen your intuition about
corporate strategy, but it also has the potential for
a huge upside reward if you haven't been initiated into
the new "real options way of thinking."
Alexander Triantis, University of Maryland, in Risk
Magazine, September 1999.
>>
back to top
What
Jeff Skilling, former CEO of Enron says
"A very lucid and concise presentation of the applications
of modern option pricing theory to the valuation of
non-traded assets. This book's approach will change
corporate decision making in areas such as strategic
investment in fixed assets and the selection of R&D
projects. The theoretical framework shows how a corporation
can consistently evaluate and compare its alternatives,
whether they be to invest in financial markets or in
physical assets."
Jeffrey Skilling, former CEO, Enron Corporation
>>
back to top
|